Author Archive

Dave Winer: Google is Evil for Fighting Malware

Monday, March 10th, 2008

Dave Winer links today to a blogger who declares Google = evil because his site shows up with a “This site may harm your computer” warning in Google search results. “I’ve reposted his piece here in full, in case Google/Firefox is blocking his site,” Winer writes.

Neither Winer nor the blogger appears to have made any attempt to learn why this happens.

When Google detects known malware on a site, it puts up the warning to let people know it’s a dangerous site to visit. Google also posts information on the Google Webmaster console for that site, so the webmaster can find out what triggered the warning.

In this case, the blogger’s using WordPress on Bluehost. The most likely cause for the warning is that old versions of WordPress have security vulnerabilities that can be exploited to add malware. This blog was probably hit before WordPress was upgraded.

Google’s doing the right thing here. There was malware on this blogger’s site that could have done any number of evil things to his visitors (some of which are legally actionable). Instead of turning a blind eye, Google flagged the problem.

Winer and the blogger could have learned all of this by searching evil Google for the phrase “This site may harm your computer.”

Dave Winer Pulls Rank on Ted Dziuba

Friday, March 7th, 2008

Silly Ass Quotes honored this recent exchange in the comments on Scripting News about the new Pownce API:

Ted Dziuba:

The pownce version requires me to log in and the twitter version does not. I detect fail.

In other news, the rest of the world does not care about this.

Dave Winer:

It’s hard is create something that people want to use, at least they’re trying to do that at Pownce. You haven’t created anything anyone wants to use, when you have, I’ll care about your opinion.

Dziuba’s the former Uncov writer who’s one of the founders of Persai, smart-filtering RSS reader startup that will sift through feeds you read to separate signal from noise.

That software sounds impressive, but until it can push high-resolution photos to my TV or create OPML outlines it’s a total fail.

Dave Winer Did Not Invent Blogging

Monday, March 3rd, 2008

Dave Winer constantly pimps for credit in any field he’s touched the last 20 years. His latest complaint is that Wikipedia gives him no props for blogging:

I looked up blogging to find the names of some more obscure ones, the first hit was the Wikipedia page, and out of curiosity I searched the page for my name. It’s not there. All kinds of people get credit for building blogging as a practice and tools for blogging, but apparently, according to Wikipedia, I had nothing to do with it, nor did Scripting News or UserLand

He took this complaint to TechCrunch as well:

By coincidence yesterday I wrote up a long-standing issue I have with Wikipedia, that I don’t get any mention in articles on blogging (and also RSS though I didn’t mention that in yesterday’s piece). I’ve raised it quite a few times, even to the visionary, but since I’m not available for ‘fucking his brains out 24 hours straigHt’, the problem has never been turned over to his internal fix-committee, and people who want to know about blogging or RSS get the idea that other people did the work and took the risks that I did.

As time passes, Winer’s claim to have fathered blogging is being ignored by more writers who cover the subject. Scripting News began eight months before the term weblog was coined by Jorn Barger in December 1997, so Winer’s claim is based on the shaky premise that his site was so distinctively a blog and so popular he should be called the leading originator of the form.

Wikipedia’s approach is eminently reasonable. It puts the coinage of the term weblog in context with a lot of bloglike sites that preceded it, many of which came long before Scripting News. NPR’s Andy Carvin also wrote a history of blogging that didn’t buy Winer’s bullshit.

Dave Winer is not the “blogfather.” He did not invent blogging. The medium was named by others and his role as an early adopter was no bigger than dozens of other writers and developers such as Barger, Peter Merholz, Cameron Barrett, Evan Williams and Ben and Mena Trott.

Winer should reconsider his decision not to sex up Wales, the former porn exec who’s newly unattached. They have a lot in common.

More on Dave Winer’s FlickrFan Lock-In

Thursday, February 28th, 2008

Some readers aren’t clear on why it’s hypocritical as hell for Dave Winer to invent a new HTTP header to lock out other applications from accessing the photo RSS feeds used by FlickrFan. Winer’s fearmongering about FeedBurner should make the point clear. Last year, in one of his efforts to spread FUD against Google’s feed publishing service, Winer wrote:

… if Google ties Feedburner to Google Reader that still hurts people like me, because my feed doesn’t work as well with Google Reader.

Now let’s take a deeper look at “doesn’t work as well.”

It could end up meaning “doesn’t work at all.” It’s quite possible in the second or third iteration that Google drops support for non-Feedburner feeds. It wouldn’t be unprecedented, far from it. Google Blogoscoped has a list of Google products that “prefer” other Google products. I’ve never seen Google not do this when they had the chance. The instant they bought Blogger they tied it to their toolbar. If they had used an open API the toolbar would have worked with all blogging tools. Google just doesn’t think that way, sorry to say.

The ability of one user to opt out would do absolutely nothing to stop or even diminish the negative effects of monopolistic tying. And users show no inclination to do anything for the benefit of the Internet as a whole, so there’s no reason to believe any of them would withhold their support of Feedburner just because it screws with the benefits of a level playing field in the RSS ecosystem. Certainly not enough to persuade Google not to tie the two products.

Several programmers used Winer’s new RSS feeds to display photos without FlickrFan, either because they don’t use Macs or because OPML Editor runs like ass. Those programs don’t work at all now. Winer’s belief in a level playing field in the RSS ecosystem only applies to other people.

Remember that the next time he complains about being locked in a trunk.

Put a Filter on Dave Winer’s RSS

Friday, February 22nd, 2008

In Slate, Paul Boutin explains one of the weaknesses of RSS:

… my RSS reader is only as smart and attentive as I am. It hasn’t figured out that I’ve stopped reading 14 of the 15 Wired.com feeds I subscribed to when I worked there last year. It can’t tell that I only care for about one in 20 of Dave Winer’s nonstop posts, and it has no way of guessing which one that will be.

Boutin, a contributor to ValleyWag, seems to think that a new smart-filtering RSS reader called Persai can handle the herculean task of figuring out which of Winer’s weblog posts is worth a read.

New Twitter Error Screen

Friday, February 15th, 2008

Vincent Ferrari has created his own Twitter error screen in honor of Dave Winer:

Dave Winer Twitter error screen

Ferrari, another unsatisfied customer of Radio Luserland, rips Winer frequently on his blog. Quote: “I find him to be a pompous bore with a big ego and a sour attitude. I’ve acknowledged his accomplishments and what he’s done for blogging (RSS? Nice job!) but I can’t get past what an annoying pissant he is.”

Dave Winer: Republicans Shit on My Dreams

Thursday, February 14th, 2008

Dave Winer on Twitter today:

the thing that radicalized me this year was when the clintons started shitting on obama. he can take it, for sure, but… about 2 hours ago

they were shitting on other people’s dreams, the same way the republicans have been shitting on mine for YEARS. actually decades. about 2 hours ago

with Reagan they put a smiley face on it. Bush, not so much, more of a snarl. openly corrupt. who the fuck cares what you think, they say. about 2 hours ago

we got 51 percent and that’s all we need. the rest of you, fuck off. (and most of the 51 percent fuck off too.) about 2 hours ago

we have been raped. and with what the clintons were doing almost lynched. you’d think they would have apologized, but that’s the way it is. about 2 hours ago

anyway, it’s going to be a fight, but its worth a fight. i wish my uncle had lived, he never would believe what’s going on now. about 2 hours ago

More than 4,600 people are sucking down this effluent on Twitter.

What dreams of Dave Winer and his uncle Ken Kiesler have the Republicans and/or Clintons been shitting on when they weren’t busy raping or lynching them? Winer’s a rich dot-com software developer living in Berkeley. From Winer’s account, his late uncle was a hippie commune dweller who lived an indolent and happy life in Jamaica.

As much as I’d love to bash Republicans — I don’t see eye to eye with Eye on politics — I’m having a little trouble finding the persecuted victims here.

Dave Winer Absent from Seesmic Investor List

Wednesday, February 13th, 2008

In the midst of pimping Seesmic last fall, Dave Winer announced that he was an investor in Loic Le Meur’s company.

Today, however, as news broke that the video-blogging startup had raised $6 million, Winer’s name was nowhere to be found among the investors:

The complete list of investors is:
  • Michael Arrington – Founder, TechCrunch
  • Steve Case – Co-Founder and former CEO and Chairman, AOL
  • Jeff Clavier – Managing Partner, SoftTech VC
  • Ron Conway – Early investor, Google
  • Steve Garfield – Pioneering video blogger
  • Dan Gillmor – Director, Knight Center for Digital Media Entrepreneurship
  • Reid Hoffman – Founder, LinkedIn
  • Michael Parekh – Managing Director, Goldman Sachs
  • Mark Pincus – Co-Founder and former Chairman and CEO, SupportSoft
  • Ariel Poler – Founder and former CEO, IPRO and Topica
  • Jeff Pulver – Chairman and Founder, Pulver.com
  • Martin Varsavsky – Founder, FON

Winer’s also missing from the investor list on the company web site and hasn’t posted anything about Seesmic in months.

What gives? Could Le Meur or the other Seesmic execs have looked at the year-long flamewar between Winer and Jason Calacanis and figured out, as Adam Curry and Ron Bloom did with PodShow, that Winer might become an embarrassment to the venture?

Update: Winer posted a response — the stock market scared him off making the investment. Lucky Loic.

Dave Winer’s Advice to Yahoo

Thursday, February 7th, 2008

As he’s telling Yahoo to sell to Microsoft, Dave Winer sneaks in his favorite advice:

Turn Yahoo into The RSS Powerhouse in every way. Build all new systems around RSS. If it isn’t RSS it doesn’t fly.

Winer frequently asserts that companies can change their fortunes by adopting RSS, and by RSS he means RSS 2.0 and not Atom like those donkey fuckers at Google.

Yahoo went bigger into RSS the past decade than anybody. The company has millions of users subscribing to RSS headlines on My Yahoo, developers remixing RSS on Yahoo Pipes, and millions more reading thousands of RSS feeds produced by its various properties. It also taught RSS to many people through its Publisher’s Guide to RSS, created the popular MediaRSS namespace, joined the RSS Advisory Board and embraced podcasting with the now-dead Yahoo Podcasts portal.

Yahoo already is an RSS powerhouse. Maybe it helped, but embracing RSS clearly wasn’t enough to keep Wall Street happy and avoid its current troubles.

When it comes to thinking about RSS, Winer’s brain is stuck in the Wayback Machine where RSS is an unproven commodity and people are still using XML icons and coffee mugs to subscribe to feeds.

Dave Winer, Unmarried Man

Wednesday, February 6th, 2008

On Aug. 31, 1986, Knight-Ridder Newspapers ran a feature story on the 3.6 million never-married American bachelors. You might recognize one of them.

THE UNMARRIED MAN 3.6 MILLION LIVE ALONE, DELAYING MARRIAGE FOR CAREER

DAVE O’BRIAN, Knight-Ridder Newspapers

When Dave Winer comes home late after a hard day at the office, no one is there to greet him. But he doesn’t really mind, he says, because he is hardly ever home.

And though he may be by himself, he is not exactly alone. He is one of 3.6 million American males who live by themselves and have never married.

More than a blip on a demographic chart, Winer’s group has grown 124 percent during the past 15 years, according to a 1985 Marital Status Report by the U.S. Census Bureau. Much has been written about the alleged plight of “older single women” — including the recent press furor over “Marriage Patterns in the United States,” a controversial Harvard-Yale study which concluded that single women over 30 have little chance to make it to the altar and that after 40 they have virtually no chance at all. Never mind that the study’s results were questionable. The single, never-married American male remains a species that seems to have been all but ignored.

(more…)